It’s a Man’s World

“It’s a Man’s World”

One of Shakespeare’s favorite plot devices seems to be putting female characters into male attire to give them a sense of power. We see this in “Twelfth Night” as well as in “Merchant of Venice”. Not only does Jessica dress as a boy in the 2nd act to escape her father, but Portia and Nerissa enter the 4th act dressed as men. This is an interesting development for Portia who had so little power in the previous acts of the play; she was bound by her father’s will and unable to choose her own husband.

However, when Antonio demands, “Most heartily I do beseech the court/To give the judgment” (4.1. 238) Portia delivers the verdict. She determines the climax of the plot. Her character has gone from having no power and being subjected to a game of a chance to being the one that determines if Antonio will live or die. Portia’s transformation is due to the fact that she is disguised as a man. Although she showcases her wit in the 1st act when she is listing the faults in her suitors and her education is obvious when she tells Nerissa, “You know I say nothing to him, for he understands not me, nor I him. He hath neither Latin, French, nor Italian” (1.2. 57-58) it is not until she is dressed as a man that these qualities are fully displayed. As she reads over the bond that Shylock and Antonio have she is able to think of a way to save Antonio. She is clever enough to read between the lines and see that the bond does not account for Shylock taking Antonio’s blood, “There is something else. /This bond doth give thee here no jot of blood” (4.1.300-301). The men who knew the circumstances of the bond failed to come up with a way to save to Antonio. They were merely counting on Shylock’s mercy (even though he refused to show any) and the Duke giving pardon to Antonio.

Portia is clearly a strong female character in the first acts, but her gender allows her to be controlled. When she puts on the male clothes she takes control of the courtroom as soon as she enters it. She determines the right justice to pass for the good of Venice; she knows that if the Duke pardons Antonio it will hurt Venice’s commerce. Economics is a sphere that women traditionally were not a part of, but Portia is smart enough to know the ins-and-outs of the Venetian market. She is also wise enough to spot the loop hole to stop Shylock from extracting his payment from Antonio. Portia was the one clever and cunning enough to save Antonio. It is ironic that she was able to save him from his bond but could not save herself from marriage. Thankfully Bassanio chose the correct casket. Portia is not able to display these strong attributes until she is dressed as a man. She is powerless and controlled as a woman, but as a man she is in charge and able to show her intelligence.  

3 thoughts on “It’s a Man’s World

  1. Sam Montagna

    I think it is funny that women were considered the weaker sex. They were told they were no better than housework and having children. According to the men of the time, women were not even smart enough to think of anything else to do. However, Portia is proof that there were women who were just as smart and brilliant as the men, maybe even more so. This blog is correct in saying that she is the one to save Antonio, yet when the man's clothing come off, she is regarded as just another woman. What's an even bigger shame is that because she was disguised, she will not even receive any credit for saving Antonio and being smarter than everyone. The merchants will never know how big of a role she actually played.

  2. Tori Holm

    I also find the aspect of women power within Shakespeare’s plays something very interesting. I was intrigued within your post when you commented on how Portia has no power within her woman body but once she hides that aspect under a man’s clothes, she has all the power. Now, as you say, it is true that within that time period women had no power. For example, they could not even act within Shakespeare’s plays, a young boy needed to play the character. Now if women were lacking in power, why is it that Shakespeare gives the most power to the woman in the play. He could have had Lancelot to ride in and save the day, but he specifically had Portia. I am curious as to why Shakespeare was so partial to his women characters. Perhaps he was a feminist before his time?

  3. Ally Farzetta

    I always love a strong female character in Shakespeare's works. Another thing I love about Portia is that she is EVEN able to outsmart her husband into giving away his wedding ring. Bassanio may think he is smarter and wittier, but it is his wife who saves the day. And after she proves her valor and intelligence, she decides to engage in a battle of wits against her husband to test his word. He obviously fails. Sneaky? Yes. But she pulls it off flawlessly. Got to give her credit for that one.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s