Suicide in Shakespeare

I find it interesting that there are so many characters who commit suicide in Shakespeare especially after reading how Ophelia’s death is handled. Looking back on other readings, not all suicides were portrayed with the same negative connotations. This leaves me wondering what Shakespeare and his audience would have thought about suicide.

Ophelia has gone mad with the grief of the loss of her father and her love (for Hamlet) being denied. She completely falls apart, climbs up a tree and decorates it with flowers. The tree represents mourning yet she decorates it with flowers that symbolize fertility. While she is in the tree she falls into a stream and drowns. Because she does not try to swim ashore, her death is pronounced a suicide.

We see from the clowns’ reactions to the burial that suicide is more than frowned upon. They question where she is being buried. Typically when people committed suicide their bodies were not given a Christian burial (not permitted in the church blessed graveyard). The priest allows trumpets and flowers and said a few prayers because of the insistence of the king, but refuses more because of the suspicion of suicide. He says rather than prayers she should have stones thrown on her.

“She should in ground unsanctified have lodged
Till the last trumpet. For charitable prayers
Shards, flints and pebbles should be thrown on her.” (5.1.203-205)

He goes as far as to refuse more prayers because it would “profane the service of the dead”(219)

These are very strong cultural beliefs regarding the subject of suicide – yet Hamlet contemplates. “To be, or not to be; that is the question:” (3.1.58) He decides against it because “for in that sleep of death what dreams may come”.(3.1.68) Hamlet is afraid of what happens to him after death.

We saw a different perspective altogether in the suicide of Othello. After murdering his his wife, Desdemona, Othello finds out the truth; she has been faithful. The remorse overcomes him and he begs to be remembered as loved, wise, yet made a mistake, not jealous but tricked, who threw away the best thing he ever had.
“Of one that loved not wisely, but too well.
Of one not easily jealous, but being wrought,
Perplexed in the extreme. Of one whose hand,
Like the base Indian, threw a pearl away
Richer than all his tribe. Of one whose subdued eyes,
Albeit unused to the melting mood,
Drop tears as fast as the Arabian trees
Their medicinal gum.” (Othello 5.2.361-369)
Othello then stabs himself to try to die with some dignity. This is a stark contrast to the fear Hamlet feels and the shame that the priest and gravediggers feel Ophelia deserves.

Romeo and Juliet’s double suicide bring a feud to a halt and is honored with monuments.

In King Lear, Gloucester wants to jump off a cliff to kill himself. In this play a madman (his son in disguise) protects Gloucester from the negative connotations of suicide by tricking him into believing that he has survived the attempt.

In these four plays we see suicide portrayed as a sin to be feared and an honorable deed; split down the middle. We know that, religiously speaking, suicide is a sin. We also see instances of suicide as a way to preserve one’s honor. So I can’t help but wonder: how does Shakespeare feel about suicide?

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Suicide in Shakespeare

  1. Michelle Cavitolo

    I found your post to be very insightful. I actually haven’t considered how Shakespeare feels about suicide, but based on the plays you mentioned above (and the one we’re reading), I think that Shakespeare was using suicide as more of a moral. True, many characters in these plays committed suicide so they could die with dignity, out of honor, etc, but maybe it’s supposed to be a reflection of how we react to situations in which we are too emotionally damaged to resolve. Suicide is a quick, permanent solution–albeit not a justifiable one–and I think Shakespeare is trying to tell us that suicide is not the way to solve problems.

    Consider what happened in the last play we read (as it’s the one I can talk about the most)–Othello killed himself because he couldn’t stand to live with the guilt of murdering his faithful wife. He died, but the play continued going. Nothing was “solved,” except for where all the Desdemona slandering was coming from. Iago gets thrown in jail, Cassio moves up… all these could have taken place if Othello was still alive and different events would have occurred.

    Reply
  2. michaeldrago

    Even today, the issue of suicide tends to be a powerful one in fiction, given that we’re all bound to have strong feelings on the subject one way or another. I would imagine that, given the fact that the personal feelings towards the issue in Shakepseare’s time were likely even stronger than they are now, these scenes had even more weight to them than they do to us. Something like Hamet’s “To be or not to be” speech is a powerful indication of the character’s inner torment, and the audiences back then probably felt the impact even more.

    Reply
  3. gerouc1

    You have made some truly excellent connections to other characters and plays in this post. Some of which I had never considered before (specifically the Othello note that you pointed out). I am half inclined now to go through all the different plays and find other sections about suicide so see if we can find a commonality among them.

    Reply
  4. Diana

    I really enjoyed your post! I like that you drew upon the previous Shakespeare plays that we have read in order to establish a connection (or a differentiation) between them. I think Shakespeare ultimately masks his own feelings and judgments on suicide by showing us two plays that are in opposition to each other in terms of suicide. I tend to think Shakespeare is someone who is very observant of society and likes to make social commentary based on his own interpretations of his observations—perhaps we will never know how exactly Shakespeare feels, but we are given different circumstances that handle (nearly) the same situation differently, as you have stated in your blog post. I think Shakespeare tries to bring our awareness to the many different “lenses” through which these deep, moral, societal issues can be viewed. I also think that he enjoys the fact that his readers don’t necessarily know how he feels about the subject he writes about 🙂 He probably likes making his readers keep guessing because it stimulates their minds and causes them to keep thinking . . .

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s